
“I don’t have scientific explanation for this. In terms of genetics horse has 64 chromosomes and donkey 62. Mule is 63 which can’t shared to two equal part, and sterile. Study of this donkey genetics can give possible answer.” Ethiopian Bio and Emerging Technology Institute (BETin) Deputy Director General Dr. Hailu Dadi
Biologically horses have 64 chromosomes while donkeys have 62 mules and the crosses between a female horse and a male donkey, mule, have 63 chromosomes. Therefore, due to the odd number of chromosomes and the fact that only 19 pairs can actually share information, mules can’t reproduce.
Contrary to this scientific fact, a mule has got to a baby in the Bako Tibe district of West Shewa Zone, Oromia Region, a local media report indicated.
The owner of the mule, Birhanu Temtay said that he had bout the animal in 2022, and was using it to pull a cart.
“I noticed that the mule’s belly was getting bigger and she gave birth on 23 May, 2023 at 11:30 a∙m∙” he said.
But, he didn’t realize that the mule would have foal and was surprised by the incident.
According to the report the foal is currently in good health condition.
A veterinarian at the Bako Tibe District Agriculture Office Dr. Lema Ayele said that he had never seen a mule giving birth to a foal, describing the situation as a new phenomenon.
Scientific and traditional credence indicates that there is a possibility one in a million mules, he said.
Ethiopian Bio and Emerging Technology Institute (BETin) Deputy Director General Dr. Hailu Dadi, animal genetic expert, who is approached by www.africandemystifier.com to reflect his view on this issue, said that similar reports has been documented in few other countries around the world.
Dr. Hailu, one of the leading Ethiopian animal genetic expert, said that he has no scientific explanation to give at hand and he pointed out that the reason why mules could not reproduce is due to their odd number of Chromosomes (23 in number in donkey) which can not equally shared with the other parent.
Dr. Hailu also suggested for a scientific genetic research to find out the exact explanation regarding this rare reports.
Scientific evidences from ScienceDiret and Donkey Sanctuary also show that the mule is a cross between a female horse and a male donkey, and the hinny is a cross between a female donkey and a male horse. The males of both crosses show abnormalities of chromosome pairing at the pachytene stage of meiotic prophase, and little or no mature spermatozoa are produced.

The mule is a cross between a female horse and a male donkey, and the hinny is a cross between a female donkey and a male horse.
Male is a ‘horse mule’ (also known as a ‘john’ or ‘jack’). Female is a ‘mare mule’ (also known as a ‘molly’).A male mule is called a john. A female mule is called a molly. A male donkey is called a jack and can be bred with a female horse to create a mule. A female donkey is called a jennet and can be bred with a male horse to create a hinny.
There are likely more cases of mules/hinnies reproducing than we know especially in developing countries. Most recent cases of mules producing foals have been documented in Morrocco (late 1990s), China (hinny that produced a foal named Dragon in the 1980s), and most recently, a mule bred to a jack in a pasture in Colorado in 2008.
Most documented cases of mules/hinnies being fertile have been in the female mule (molly/mare mule). A majority of male mules/hinnies are castrated, but one case of a fertile hinny producing live, mature spermatozoa was documented at Texas A&M in the 1950s.
Also, mare mules have been used successfully as recipients. Colorado State University several years ago was successful in doing so.
